Image: Getty Images
It’s meant to be the surest bet you can make. Invest in education, the mantra goes, and you’ll reap a lifetime of rewards. Yet for a growing number of people, that bargain is breaking down. The master’s degree, once a reliable ticket to the professional class, is looking more and more like a waste of time and money. In America two in five of these programmes fail to deliver a positive financial return. In Britain a quarter of male graduates earn less than their non-graduate peers. The escalator of social mobility is stalling.
This isn’t because learning has lost its worth. It’s because the economics of higher education have become unmoored from reality. Universities are churning out advanced degrees at a rate the labour market cannot possibly absorb while charging ever more for them. Employers, flooded with credentials, are downgrading their value. What was sold as a shortcut to prosperity is, for many, a detour into debt.
How did this happen? For years the maths worked. The “college premium”—the wage bump from getting a degree—was juicy. But as more people piled in, the returns began to sink. The master’s degree offered a way to stand out and universities were happy to oblige. They discovered a perfect product: shorter than a bachelor’s, more profitable and cheap to deliver. In America graduate programmes now bring in more money than undergraduate ones. In Britain high fees from postgraduates plug holes in finances strained by caps on home-student tuition.
The incentives here are all wrong. Universities are rewarded for enrolment numbers and research, rather than for whether their graduates find decent jobs. So they market advanced degrees as career advancement even when the payoff is slim. Governments, keen to boost headline education figures, tended to play along. The result is a self-reinforcing cycle: more students enrol, universities expand, credentials multiply and their value tumble. It’s a speculative bubble with human potential as the overhyped asset.
Employers aren’t blind to this. In fast-moving fields like tech, firms are dropping degree requirements altogether, preferring proven skills to paper qualifications. IBM now requires a degree for only half its roles. A portfolio of coding projects can be more telling than a master’s in computer science. The shelf-life of knowledge in many disciplines is short: a two-year course can lag behind the frontier from day one.
Even the doctorate, the pinnacle of academic achievement, is losing its lustre. Universities benefit enormously from doctoral students, who provide cheap teaching and research labour. But only a fraction land the tenure-track jobs they were trained for. The financial premium for a PhD is generally vanishingly small. Those who pursue one do so for love not money, a passion the system readily exploits.
The problem wears different guises in different places. In America it’s a mountain of debt, now over $1.7trn. In Europe it’s underemployment with graduates serving coffee. In emerging economies it’s a brutal mismatch. India produces over a million postgraduates a year but not enough graduate-level jobs. China, with a record 11m new graduates in 2023, tells its youth to “lower expectations” and head to the countryside. It’s a poor return on years of study.
This isn’t just a tragedy for individuals: it’s a drag on entire economies. When societies pour vast resources into credentials that don’t build useful skills, talent and capital are misallocated. Productivity suffers. The education bubble may be made of paper, but its pop will be felt in flesh and blood.
What’s to be done? Governments are tinkering at the edges, linking funding to graduate outcomes or nudging students towards more vocational fields. Such reforms are politically tricky: universities hate interference and students resent being told what’s “worth” studying. But without some accountability, the market will keep overproducing worthless degrees.
The onus is also on students and their families to be savvier. The value of a degree now depends far more on the subject than the brand. Engineering or nursing are safer bets than fine arts or sociology. Completing courses on time matters, too. And everyone should ask the most brutal question before enrolling: what’s the opportunity cost?
The master’s degree is a victim of its own success. It has become so common that it no longer signals distinction, only conformity. The system that was meant to foster critical thinking has become a herd activity. For societies broad education is still a wonderful good. But for the individual, it’s time to read the small print. ■
